Clients don't care about agencies. And why should they?
I spent ten years on the client side at Disney. I understand the mindset. Your job is to protect your business. Deliver results. Manage budgets. Make your boss happy. And ultimately secure your job.
Whether your agency makes a healthy margin isn't really your problem. Or is it?
The unwritten rules
WPP and Publicis have been having a very public argument about pitching. WPP's Cindy Rose says clients who hand over accounts without a pitch are skipping due diligence. Publicis says that insults clients' intelligence. I think they're both touching on something much bigger.
For decades, agencies have accepted the unwritten rules. Pitch for free. Commit weeks of senior time. Develop ideas and strategies you might never get paid for. Accept procurement pressure. And hope the next win makes the economics work.
The average pitch costs a non-incumbent agency more than $200,000, and costs the client about twice that (ANA and 4A's, The Cost of the Pitch). A holding company can absorb that. An independent with 50 people cannot.
The rules favour the big agencies. But even they are now squeezed by rising costs and falling margins.
The irony
When senior people leave client-side roles, where do many of them turn? The agencies. The same businesses they've spent years squeezing on price and demanding more from. And increasingly, those agencies can't afford to hire them.
What should change
I'm not suggesting clients should subsidise poorly run agencies. Far from it. But if you want brilliant creative thinking, you need businesses that can afford to invest in brilliant people.
I have no problem with agencies competing for work. I do have a problem with the unwritten rules.
- If you already know who you want, cut to the chase.
- If the process needs weeks of strategic and creative development, pay for it.
- If you use ideas from an unsuccessful agency, compensate them.
- Put reasonable limits on the time and resources expected.
Because if clients keep treating agencies as disposable suppliers, they'll discover the agencies they actually want to work with are losing their best people. Or gone.